News

Court Awards #20 Million Damages Against EEDC

The High Court of Imo State has delivered its final judgment in a suit arising from the unlawful disconnection of electricity supply, in the case between KIE Augustine Esq. and Hon. Vitalis Opara, Plaintiffs, and Enugu Electricity Distribution Company (EEDC) and Tochukwu, Defendants.

In its considered decision, the court held the 1st Defendant liable for acts of lawlessness in the disconnection of electricity supply to the Plaintiffs’ premises, while declining to grant some of the reliefs sought.

The judgment, as contained in the Certified True Copy of the court’s final analysis, reflects a careful evaluation of the facts presented, the applicable law, and the extent of the reliefs proved before the court.

The court found that the Plaintiffs substantially succeeded in establishing their case.

However, it made it clear that not all the claims advanced were supported by sufficient and credible evidence.

In particular, the court rejected certain allegations against the 1st Defendant, holding that they were not proved to the standard required by law.

In the words of the court, “the Plaintiffs have proved their case except that their reliefs No. 6 and 11 on alleged use of hired thugs by the 1st Defendant and cost of litigation of ₦2,000,000.00, are not made out and are hence refused accordingly.”

By this finding, the court dismissed the claims relating to the alleged use of hired thugs and the request for litigation costs, emphasizing the principle that serious allegations must be strictly proved.

Notwithstanding the refusal of those reliefs, the court took a firm position on the issue of unlawful disconnection of electricity supply.

It held that the action of the 1st Defendant was contrary to established standards and regulatory procedures governing electricity distribution.

The Plaintiffs had claimed the sum of ₦500,000,000.00 as general damages for the wrongful acts of the Defendant. In addressing this relief, the court held that while the Plaintiffs were entitled to compensation, the amount claimed was excessive.

Accordingly, the court ruled as follows: “However, as regards relief No. 10 for ₦500,000,000.00 general damages, same is hereby assessed at ₦20,000,000.00 only against the 1st Defendant for their brazen act of lawlessness in disconnecting electric power supply to the Plaintiffs’ premises, contrary to established standards.”

The judgment therefore resulted in a partial victory for the Plaintiffs, who were awarded the sum of ₦20 million as general damages, while other unproven reliefs were dismissed.

The decision serves as a clear warning to electricity distribution companies and other service providers on the need to comply strictly with due process and regulatory guidelines in their dealings with consumers.

Overall, the judgment stands as a significant pronouncement on consumer rights and corporate accountability, reinforcing the position that unlawful disconnection of essential services will attract judicial sanctions, while also affirming the courts’ commitment to refusing claims that are not properly established by evidence.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button