Featured

“Partial” Local Government Autonomy: Already Ambushed, Kidnapped

By Willie Amadi

The genuine intention of President Tinubu’s administration to rescue the third tier of government from financial bondage, as stipulated under section 2 of the 1999 Constitution, is dead on arrival.

The Supreme Court judgment’s benefits and implications are well-known.

The silence and passive acceptance from the powerful governors as PBAT and the Supreme Court issued their judgments were strategic, aimed at soothing political tensions.

Firstly, elections in the 774 local government councils, conducted under the strict control and manipulation of the governors, essentially extend the operations of the executive branch.

Candidates are hand-picked by the governors through their agents at the local levels.

The Chairman and members of the Electoral Commission are also chosen by the governors from party members or loyalists, with funding provided by the governors, thereby ensuring their influence.

Secondly, local government administration laws in various states grant state houses of assembly exclusive powers to control, discipline, and regulate local government functions.

All houses of assembly, effectively extensions of the executive arm, derive their impetus and direction from the executive branch headed by their governors.

Speakers act as agents and informants within the legislative branch on behalf of the governors.

This undermines legislative independence. Notably, during the last constitutional amendment process under the Buhari administration, all but four state houses of assembly voted against financial autonomy.

Thirdly, the pervasive hunger in the land ensures that local government chairmen and councilors cannot ignore, dispute, or refuse directives from the governors under the threat of suspension.

As per the local government administration laws in place since 1999, allegations of misappropriation or embezzlement can lead to immediate suspension and the formation of an inquiry panel.

For instance, the Imo State Local Government Administration Law of 2001 (as amended) exemplifies this.

Finally, without a protective framework designed by the Honorable Attorney General of the Federation, supported by an Executive Order to enforce the direct allocation of local government revenue from the Federation account, the Supreme Court judgment is rendered ineffective.

Any judgment that cannot be enforced is as worthless as the paper it is written on.

It is my considered recommendation that PBAT, alongside this landmark judgment, appoint 774 Presidential Liaison Officers drawn from the clergy, EFCC, ICPC, civil society organizations, and local stakeholders to monitor the application of funds directly for local government needs as outlined in their budgets.

Governors, as the Chief Security Officers of their states, should play a partnership role rather than acting as financial controllers.

INEC-conducted elections, a review of local government administration laws in the 36 states, and local stakeholder participation would enhance the benefits of local government autonomy.

It is never too late to correct mistakes, and the time is NOW!

Epilogue: The Journey to Local Government Financial Autonomy.

MAY 2020 — PMB signed an Executive Order granting financial autonomy to the Judiciary, Legislature, & LGAs (The Guardian).

OCT 2021 — 36 state governments sued the FG at the Supreme Court over Executive Order 10 (Premium Times).

FEB 2022 — The Supreme Court declared Executive Order 10 unlawful and unconstitutional (Channels).

MAR 2022 — The Senate passed a bill to grant LGAs financial and administrative autonomy (Premium Times).

MAY 2022 — The FG won a case against state governors over the LGA Joint Account Financial Autonomy (Channels).

MAY 2024 — The FG filed a suit at the Supreme Court seeking full autonomy for LGAs (Premium Times).

JUL 2024— The Supreme Court granted financial autonomy to LGAs (Vanguard).

Statisense

Willie Amadi, a lawyer and environmentalist, writes from Owerri.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button