News

THE UMUDIBIA PARADOX: Orashi Petroleum Came With a Community Engagement Agenda—So Why Does the Community Feel Excluded?

A Host Community Development Trust is supposed to empower host communities.

But in Umudibia, growing concerns over representation threaten to undermine what should have been a landmark partnership between Orashi Petroleum and its host community.

When Engr. Nnanna Charles Ukaegbu, the Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer of Orashi Petroleum Development Company Limited arrived in Umudibia to engage the community on the Host Community Development Trust (HCDT) framework under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), many expected the beginning of a new chapter.

It should have been a win-win moment. A respected professional and accomplished engineer leading a strategic oil and gas project had come to engage a host community that would inevitably play a critical role in the success of the Iheoma Marginal Field Project.

The expectations were high. The opportunities were immense. The legal framework was clear.

Yet, what should have inspired confidence has instead generated anxiety, suspicion and growing calls for due process among many members of the Umudibia community. The irony is difficult to ignore.

The company came to discuss community engagement. Yet many within the community now complain that the engagement process itself failed to engage the community.

That contradiction lies at the heart of the controversy currently unfolding in Umudibia.

A PRESENTATION THAT SAID THE RIGHT THINGS

The Host Community Development Trust presentation delivered by Orashi Petroleum outlined the noble objectives of the Petroleum Industry Act.

The document emphasized sustainable prosperity, peaceful coexistence, direct social and economic benefits and the establishment of a transparent development framework for host communities.

The presentation further identified stakeholder dialogue, regular sensitization programmes and transparent identification processes as critical components of successful host-community relations.

Most significantly, the presentation explicitly states that communities nominate their representatives during the process of constituting governance structures for the Host Community Development Trust.

That provision is not accidental. It is fundamental. The Petroleum Industry Act did not create Host Community Development Trusts so that a handful of individuals could speak on behalf of entire communities.

It created them to ensure that communities themselves become active participants in decisions affecting their future.

This is where many Umudibia stakeholders believe the process may have gone wrong.

NO SINGLE INDIVIDUAL CAN APPOINT UMUDIBIA’S REPRESENTATIVES

The issue before Umudibia today is larger than any individual. It is larger than the traditional institution. It is larger than Orashi Petroleum.

It is about principle. No individual—regardless of title, status, or influence—possesses the moral authority to handpick representatives for an entire autonomous community.

Representation derives legitimacy from the people. It cannot be manufactured in a palace. It cannot be imposed through private arrangements. It cannot be delegated to loyalists.

Umudibia is not a village lacking educated people. It is not a community devoid of professionals. It is not a people incapable of organizing themselves.

Within Umudibia are lawyers, engineers, academics, administrators, business leaders, development practitioners, surveyors, economists and other professionals with the competence to represent their people.

Umudibia community possesses both the intellectual capacity and institutional maturity to nominate its own representatives.

Anything short of that principle undermines the very essence of community participation.

THE SOCIAL LICENCE TO OPERATE

Around the world, resource extraction companies increasingly recognise that obtaining government permits is not enough.

There is another licence that cannot be issued by any ministry. It is called the Social Licence to Operate. This licence is granted by the people. It is earned through trust. It is sustained through transparency. It is protected through meaningful engagement.

As community engagement experts, Kevin Preister and Doug Bannerman observed:

“Resident engagement should be at parity with technical disciplines in tactical and strategic project decision-making, promoting greater citizen ownership of projects in their communities.”

That observation is particularly relevant to Umudibia. Host-community engagement is not a ceremonial exercise. It is not a public relations activity.

It is not about gathering signatures. It is about building ownership. When communities feel ownership, projects flourish. When communities feel excluded, projects encounter resistance.

THE LESSONS OF IMO’S OIL COMMUNITIES

Imo State already provides sufficient evidence of what happens when host communities are excluded from decision-making.

In Ohaji/Egbema and Oguta, decades of oil production have not always translated into corresponding levels of development.

Many communities continue to complain about poor infrastructure, inadequate social amenities, environmental degradation and limited participation in decisions affecting their resources.

These grievances have frequently resulted in protests, disputes and strained relationships between operators and host communities.

The lesson is clear. Communities do not merely want benefits. They want inclusion. They want respect.

They want a voice. The Petroleum Industry Act was enacted precisely because previous approaches often failed to provide those things.

EVEN THE PIA RECOGNISES COMMUNITY OWNERSHIP

The Host Community Development Trust framework established under the Petroleum Industry Act represents one of the most significant reforms in Nigeria’s oil and gas sector.

The framework requires operators to contribute a percentage of operating expenditure to host-community development and establishes governance structures intended to ensure community participation.

The presentation delivered in Umudibia clearly outlines a process in which communities nominate representatives for trust structures and advisory committees.

The presentation also identifies transparent identification processes and stakeholder dialogue as solutions to community disputes.

If these principles are to have meaning, they must be reflected not only in PowerPoint presentations but also in practical implementation.

A WORD TO ORASHI PETROLEUM

This moment presents an opportunity rather than a crisis. Engr. Nnanna Charles Ukaegbu has an opportunity to demonstrate leadership.

A truly successful oil and gas project is not measured solely by production volumes. It is measured by the quality of relationships established with host communities.

If concerns exist regarding representation, the solution is not to dismiss those concerns. The solution is to broaden engagement.

The solution is transparency. The solution is dialogue. The solution is allowing the community itself to determine who speaks on its behalf.

Doing so would strengthen, not weaken, the credibility of the Host Community Development Trust process.

THE WAY FORWARD

The path forward is straightforward. First, all resolutions and agreements associated with the ongoing engagement process should be subjected to broader community review.

Second, Umudibia should convene an open and inclusive stakeholders’ forum involving youths, women, family heads, professionals, landowners, religious leaders and traditional institutions.

Third, representatives to the Host Community Development Trust should emerge through a transparent nomination process accepted by the community.

Fourth, Orashi Petroleum should continue engagement with the broader community rather than relying solely on a limited group of intermediaries.

Finally, the Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission should ensure strict compliance with both the spirit and the letter of the Petroleum Industry Act.

THE CHOICE BEFORE UMUDIBIA

The issue is not whether Orashi Petroleum should operate in Umudibia. The issue is not whether development should come.

The issue is whether development will be built on legitimacy. The future success of the Iheoma Marginal Field Project depends not only on the resources beneath Umudibia’s soil but also on the trust established with the people above it.

The people of Umudibia are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for representation. They are asking for participation.

They are asking for ownership of a process that the Petroleum Industry Act itself was designed to place in their hands.

That is not an unreasonable demand. It is, in fact, the very foundation upon which successful host-community engagement is supposed to be built.

And until that principle is respected, many within Umudibia will continue to ask a question that deserves an honest answer: How can a project founded on community engagement succeed if the community itself believes it was never truly engaged?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Nze Emmanuel Ehirim is a Corporate Communications Practitioner, public affairs analyst and community development advocate.

He is the Chief Executive Officer of the Nze Emmanuel Ehirim Social Justice Foundation and writes extensively on governance, social justice, sustainable development and community relations.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button